There is a dangerous tendency in progressive politics to explain human wrongdoing so thoroughly through the failures of society that the person who commits it almost disappears from the moral equation. Poverty becomes the culprit. Oppression becomes the culprit. The system becomes the culprit.
Somewhere beneath all those explanations lies an individual who made a decision to hurt another human being, and a victim who must now live with the consequences. My concern is what happens to a country when its institutions become more comfortable explaining those decisions than holding people responsible for them.
Evil exists, and human beings are capable of choosing it. People can recognize another person’s vulnerability and deliberately exploit it. They can understand the suffering they are causing and continue because it benefits them.
Any political philosophy that struggles to acknowledge this will struggle to protect the innocent. Eventually, its compassion for the perpetrator becomes an obligation imposed on everyone within his reach.
I understand the desire to believe that people can be redeemed. As a Christian, I believe in repentance and the possibility of profound personal change. But repentance requires acknowledging that we have done wrong and accepting responsibility for doing better.
The agency that allows a person to turn toward goodness also allows him to choose cruelty. We cannot build a coherent moral worldview by celebrating the first capacity while explaining away the second.
That is the contradiction I see running through an influential strain of progressive thinking. Its account of human behavior gives enormous weight to circumstances whenever responsibility would complicate its preferred narrative. The offender becomes someone failed by society, and enforcing consequences becomes another failure inflicted upon him.
Follow that reasoning far enough, and the institutions charged with protecting people become the principal objects of suspicion, while the people creating the danger receive an expanding list of explanations.
There is something deeply condescending about this, especially toward the poor. Millions of people endure deprivation, discrimination, and disappointment while refusing to prey upon their neighbors. They work exhausting jobs, raise their children, and keep their word when dishonesty might offer an easier path.
Their choices deserve recognition. Treating hardship as an explanation that routinely overwhelms responsibility diminishes the moral courage of everyone who faces hardship and still chooses decency.
Of course circumstances matter. A child raised amid violence faces burdens that a child raised in safety may never understand. We should help that child, strengthen his family, and give him opportunities to build a different life. But the people around him also have lives, and they deserve protection if he begins harming them. A just society must be capable of caring about his past while taking responsibility for what happens to his next potential victim.
This is where an idea becomes a governing philosophy with consequences. Once we see wrongdoing primarily as the product of an unfair system, restraint and punishment start to look like additional injustice. Removing consequences begins to feel compassionate almost by definition. The question of whether other people will be safer becomes secondary to whether the institution appears sufficiently understanding toward the person who broke the rules.
That instinct helps explain the appeal of proposals to defund police, weaken disciplinary consequences, or expand release without sufficient attention to repeated dangerous behavior. Each proposal has its own details and deserves examination on those terms.
The ideological problem emerges whenever reducing enforcement becomes a moral achievement in itself. A community measures success by whether its residents can live safely. A reform movement can lose sight of that when it becomes preoccupied with how rarely the government exercises authority.
Cashless bail belongs in that discussion because pretrial decisions carry obligations in more than one direction. A person’s freedom should receive serious consideration, and an accusation must be fairly tested. So should a credible threat against a witness, a former partner, or a neighbor.
When officials discuss release almost entirely through the hardships of detention, the frightened person waiting outside the courtroom can disappear from the conversation. She deserves a government willing to hear her before something worse happens.
The same moral imbalance can enter a classroom. A child who bullies others may need counseling, patience, and help at home. The child he terrorizes needs adults who will make the behavior stop. Imagine repeatedly telling your daughter that the school understands her fear while sending her back into the same situation. Eventually, she learns something about authority that no civics lesson can undo. She learns that adults can recognize her suffering and still expect her to absorb it.
Immigration debates reveal a related tendency to treat enforcement itself as evidence of moral failure. As someone who spent eighteen years as an immigrant before becoming an American citizen, I understand the longing for opportunity and the frustrations of a difficult process.
Humane treatment and a fair hearing matter. But a country must also be able to reach a lawful decision and carry it out. When every consequence becomes cruelty, the people asked to comply are left wondering whether compliance has any meaning.
This habit becomes particularly disturbing when political grievance softens judgment of deliberate atrocities. The sympathetic responses some social media users offered to Osama bin Laden’s Letter to America showed how readily resentment toward America could make a terrorist’s explanation seem persuasive.
The families who lost loved ones on September 11 deserve better than a moral framework in which the murderer’s grievances crowd out his responsibility. A political cause cannot confer permission to slaughter innocent people.
The celebrations that followed Charlie Kirk’s killing exposed another version of the same failure. Leaders across both parties condemned his murder, and many people who opposed his views mourned it. Others found reasons to celebrate.
Their reaction revealed the danger of allowing ideological hostility to determine whose humanity commands respect. A society cannot sustain peaceful disagreement when people begin treating the death of an opponent as a welcome political development.
The social compact depends on people believing that lawful restraint will be met with lawful protection. When that promise repeatedly fails, people withdraw their trust. Families leave, businesses close, witnesses fall silent, and those with resources purchase security that others cannot afford.
At the extreme, the retreat of legitimate authority creates room for intimidation, private retaliation, and competing sources of power. That is a path toward state failure, and a country can suffer profound damage long before it reaches the end.
We should demand institutions that protect victims, enforce fair rules, and give people meaningful opportunities to change. We should also recover the confidence to say that a person can suffer injustice and still commit injustice against someone else.
Our children deserve to inherit a country where goodness has defenders and cruelty encounters resistance.
“A society that keeps explaining away evil will eventually ask the innocent to make room for it.” — Alma Ohene-Opare



